Chivas USA: Dan Kennedy; Mario De Luna, Joaquin Velazquez, Walter Vilchez; Eric Avila, Edgar Mejia, Laurent Courtois (Bobby Burling, 56'), Giovani Casillas (Miller Bolaños, 46'), Marvin Iraheta; Julio Morales (Juan Agudelo, 46'), Tristan Bowen
Substitutes not used: Tim Melia, Jose Soto, Jose Correa, Carlos Alvarez
Columbus Crew: Andy Gruenebaum; Josh Williams, Chad Marshall, Gláuber, Tyson Wahl; Dominic Oduro, Danny O'Rourke, Agustín Viana, Eddie Gaven; Federico Higuaín (Tony Tchani, 76'), Jairo Arrieta (Ryan Finley, 76')
Substitutes not used: Matt Lampson, Drew Beckie, Matias Sanchez, Ethan Finlay, Ben Speas
Goals and Assists
| Club | Time | Player | (Assisted by) |
|---|---|---|---|
| CLB | 51' | Federico Higuaín | (Jairo Arrieta) |
| CLB | 88' | Josh Williams | (Eddie Gaven) |
| CLB | 94' | Dominic Oduro |
Disciplinary
| Club | Time | Player | Reason | Action |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CHV | 8' | Julio Morales | Foul | YELLOW |
| CHV | 28' | Eric Avila | Foul | YELLOW |
| CHV | 75' | Tristan Bowen | Foul | YELLOW |
| CHV | 79' | Marvin Iraheta | Foul | YELLOW |
| CHV | 91' | Bobby Burling | Foul | YELLOW |
