Columbus Crew: Gruenebaum; Miranda, Gehrig, Mendes, Williams; Gaven, Birchall, Tchani, Speas; Higuaín, Arrieta.
Bench: Lampson, James, Vukovic, Duka, George, Meram, Rentería
Toronto FC: Hall; J. Hall, Eckersley, Cann, Morgan; Wiedeman, Dunfield, Silva, Avila; Lambe, Johnson
Bench: Roberts; Henry, Williams, Emory, Maund, Cordon, Lindsay
Goals and Assists
| Club | Time | Player | (Assisted by) |
|---|---|---|---|
| CLB | 17' | Federico Higuaín | |
| TOR | 27' | Andrew Wiedeman | (Ryan Johnson) |
| CLB | 62' | Federico Higuaín |
Disciplinary
| Club | Time | Player | Reason | Action |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| TOR | 61' | Terry Dunfield | Foul |



